The Great Shift: Why Sellers Now Outnumber Buyers by a Record Margin

Pineyro Capital Group Residential | Commercial
Apr 1
5 min read

The U.S. housing market has hit a milestone that hasn’t been seen in over a decade. According to the latest data from Redfin, the gap between home sellers and buyers has widened to a record high, signaling a significant shift in negotiating power. Is this "the great shift?"

As of February 2026, there were 46.3% more home sellers than buyers in the market. That translates to a surplus of roughly 629,808 homes—the largest gap since record-keeping began in 2013. For comparison, that gap was only 29.8% just one year ago.

Why is This Happening?

The "lock-in effect"—where homeowners felt stuck in their low-interest mortgages—is finally beginning to thaw. Coupled with a surge in new construction, inventory is finally catching up to (and surpassing) demand.

"We’re seeing a lot more inventory on the market compared to the past two years," says Justin Gomez, a Redfin Premier agent. "This has been great for affordability, especially for the younger crowd... Two years ago, people were offering $15,000 over asking just to get a home."

Key Drivers of the Buyer Retreat:

Stubbornly High Prices: While growth has slowed, prices remain at historic peaks.
Mortgage Rates: Rates have stayed higher for longer than many anticipated.
Economic Uncertainty: Layoffs and political shifts have made potential buyers more cautious.
The "Wait and See" Approach: Many buyers are sitting on the sidelines, hoping for a significant rate drop that has yet to fully materialize.

A Tale of Two Markets: Buyers vs. Sellers. The great shift

Redfin defines a "Buyer’s Market" as any area where there are 10% more sellers than buyers. By that definition, the U.S. has been in a buyer’s market since May 2024. However, this trend isn't hitting every city the same way.

THE BUYER'S ADVANTAGE (Inventory Surplus)	THE SELLER'S EDGE (Inventory Shortage)
In these regions, buyers have massive leverage to negotiate price cuts, repairs, and incentives.	In the Northeast and Midwest, construction is slower and inventory remains tight, keeping sellers in control.
1. Miami, FL: +163% More Sellers	1. Newark, NJ: -31.1% Fewer Sellers
2. Nashville, TN: +120% More Sellers	2. Montgomery County, PA: -29.0% Fewer Sellers
3. Austin, TX: +112% More Sellers	3. Nassau County, NY: -25.8% Fewer Sellers
4. West Palm Beach, FL: +110% More Sellers	4. Milwaukee, WI: -25.2% Fewer Sellers
5. San Antonio, TX: +104% More Sellers	5. New Brunswick, NJ: -14.5% Fewer Sellers

The New Construction Impact

The South and West are leading the charge in building permits, which explains why states like Florida and Texas have transitioned so sharply into buyer’s markets. As homebuilders ramp up activity to meet previous demand, the pool of available homes has grown just as the pool of buyers has shrunk due to soaring costs.

In fact, new construction is often the primary competitor for individual sellers right now. Builders are able to offer "rate buy-downs" and incentives that traditional sellers simply can't match, forcing existing homeowners to be more aggressive with their pricing and terms.

How to Win in This Market: Helping Realtors Succeed

In a market where inventory is high and buyers are picky, standing out is no longer optional—it’s a necessity. This is where Helping Realtors Succeed, powered by Pineyro Capital Group Inc Residential and Commercial, comes in.

We understand that to sell more in a buyer's market, agents need high-end visibility and professional resources. That’s why we offer free co-branding information and marketing—totally free!—to help you elevate your brand and move listings faster.

Our Partnership Benefits Include:

Professional Co-Branded Collateral: High-quality marketing materials that feature both your expertise and our financial backing.
Residential & Commercial Support: Whether you are moving a single-family home in Austin or a commercial lot in Miami, we provide the tools to close.
Enhanced Visibility: We help you cut through the noise of a crowded market so your listings get the eyeballs they deserve.

What This Means for Your Strategy

For Buyers: If you are looking in the Sun Belt, you have the upper hand. Use our co-branded resources to show your clients the best financing options available.
For Sellers: Pricing and presentation are everything. Utilize our marketing tools to make your listing the most attractive option on the block.

The market is recalibrating. While the "feeding frenzy" of previous years is over in most of the country, the local nature of real estate means your strategy should depend entirely on your zip code. Don't navigate this shift alone—let us help you dominate your local market.

Ready to boost your sales? Contact Helping Realtors Succeed today to access your free co-branded marketing kit!

PCG residential and commercial originates commercial and residential real estate loans.

ABOUT US

Pineyro Capital Group Inc., NMLS #420112 — Your Trusted Partner in Residential & Commercial Lending. At Pineyro Capital Group Inc, our mission is simple: to help individuals and businesses achieve their goals through smart, flexible financing solutions.

Whether you're a first-time homebuyer, a seasoned real estate investor, or a business owner looking to expand, we’re here to simplify the lending process and guide you every step of the way.

Residential & Commercial Lending Expertise

With decades of combined experience, we specialize in delivering tailored loan solutions for both residential and commercial needs:

🏠 Residential Loans: From first-time homebuyers to real estate investors, we help you secure the right mortgage solution—conventional, FHA, VA, jumbo, and more.
🏢 Commercial Loans: Whether you’re acquiring property, refinancing, or funding a project, we offer customized commercial financing options to help you build and grow.

Why Choose Pineyro Capital Group?

✅ Extensive Lender Network: We work with a wide range of trusted lenders, giving you access to competitive rates, flexible programs, and fast approvals—all through one streamlined process.

✅ Expert Guidance: Our experienced team understands that no two clients are alike. We take the time to listen, educate, and advise so you can make informed decisions with confidence.

✅ Service-First Approach: From your initial consultation to closing day, we provide personalized support, clear communication, and a commitment to delivering exceptional service.

Your Success is Our Priority

At Pineyro Capital Group, we believe financing shouldn’t be complicated—it should be empowering. We’re proud to have helped hundreds of clients achieve their dreams of homeownership, investment success, and business growth.

Let’s make your next move a success. Contact us today to explore your residential or commercial loan options. We’re here to help—every step of the way.